Jury of Your Peers
Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.
Listen on:
Episodes
Aug 10, 2025
Aug 10, 2025
11 min
This bonus clip is our conversation around Shedeur Sanders and his outrageous draft slide.
This is from our very first Deliberation room episode recorded May12th, but was cut for time!
Hope you enjoy.
Aug 6, 2025
Aug 6, 2025
27 min
Lil Tay made $1M hours after turning 18—by launching an OnlyFans. We dive into the ethical chaos: online predators, age-gap discourse, legality vs morality, and the weirdos waiting in the wings. Plus: Ashley Madison, the T App, digital footprints, and what this says about sex, power, and clout in 2025. Creepy? Legal? Both?
Follow us @juryofyourpeers — and yes, we’re judging.
Jul 28, 2025
Jul 28, 2025
1hr 16 sec
In episode 10 of Jury of Your Peers, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick dive into two fiery AITA stories that spark a deeper conversation about control, consent, and the boundaries we draw with family. First, they unpack the drama when a woman says “no” to her overstepping mother-in-law — and suddenly becomes the villain. Then, a parent draws a line to protect their son’s autonomy, only to face backlash from people who refuse to respect even the most basic boundaries. The crew calls out the red flags and breaks down the emotional stakes behind these seemingly simple “asks.” in this week's episode of Jury of Your Peers.
Jul 21, 2025
Jul 21, 2025
52 min
In this spicy and unfiltered episode of Jury of Your Peers, your favorite courtroom chaos crew Paddy, Bello, and Darrien dive headfirst into the messiest relationship drama Reddit has to offer. This week’s case? A woman who found nudes, a full-blown sex tape, and Snapchat side quests galore on her boyfriend’s phone… but somehow she's being told she's the problem?!
And is asking someone to let you know when they arrive to pick you up a step too far?
Expect wild takes, unsolicited (but hilarious) legal advice, and a full breakdown on why using Snapchat after 28 might be a criminal offense.
Jul 16, 2025
Jul 16, 2025
42 min
Darrien, Paddy, and Erick break down the chaos of Love Island USA—from cast scandals to viral TikToks—all with zero filter and maximum personality. Paddy, the resident expert, leads the charge as the crew debates the infamous “Hurricane Huda,” racist cast exits, and dance drama on TikTok Live. It’s quick, witty, and wildly unpredictable.
Jul 7, 2025
Jul 7, 2025
50 min
Darrien, Erick, and Paddy return to the Supreme Court to rule on one of the internet’s most cursed love stories — Tyler Life and his infamous sex playlist featuring Hudson Mohawke’s "C-Bat." We break down the Reddit drama, the breakup, the face reveal, and deliver an official court sentence. It’s a story so bizarre, it left us questioning reality — and our eardrums.Along the way, we dive into the psychology of weird music choices, accidental gaslighting, and what kind of punishment truly fits the crime.Plus: golf picks, betting talk, and the usual chaos from your favorite internet judges.
Jul 1, 2025
Jul 1, 2025
56 min
Darrien, Paddy, and Erick face two wrenching AITA dilemmas: a parent who wipes out their child’s entire Minecraft world as punishment—sparking tears, food refusals, and furious debate on digital discipline—and someone who flat-out refuses to acknowledge their half‑sibling, insisting that blood alone doesn’t mandate bonds. Is any topic safe from the Jury of Your Peers circuit court?
Jun 25, 2025
Jun 25, 2025
30 min
In this episode of The Deliberation Room, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick unpack the emotional chaos of moving—and why relocating might be the ultimate test of patience. Then the conversation takes a left turn into the world of Tyler the Creator and a controversial quote he dropped regarding who should have platforms online before asking the important question, should we bring back carrier pigeon communication? Vulnerable, funny, and expectedly stupid, this minisode is a perfect storm of real-life stress and cultural obsession.
Jun 16, 2025
Jun 16, 2025
51 min
In this episode of Jury of Your Peers, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick dive into two blazing-hot AITA stories. First: topless sunbathing on your own property—empowered or inappropriate? When a surprise visit from in-laws leads to judgment and drama, things escalate fast. Then, it’s family chaos as one bride-to-be gets humiliated with a “gift basket” full of deodorant—courtesy of her future mother-in-law. Petty? Passive-aggressive? Or just plain toxic? The crew breaks it all down, one wild layer at a time.
Jun 9, 2025
Jun 9, 2025
51 min
In this charged episode of Jury of Your Peers, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick tackle two drastically different—but equally explosive—AITA stories. First up: is it wrong to cut off your brother before Mother’s Day when the relationship includes years of emotional manipulation and literal violence? Then things take a hard left into one man’s refusal to give his girlfriend anal or eat ass—and the breakup fallout that followed. Boundaries, sex, and Reddit chaos all collide in classic Jury of Your Peers fashion.



