Jury of Your Peers
Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.
Listen on:
Episodes
Jun 22, 2026
Jun 22, 2026
25 min
Episode 17 of JYP Deliberation Room brings the chaos, the laughs, and a bittersweet twist you didn’t see coming.
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy kick things off with real-life frustrations—from washed-out playoff dreams to brutal travel days—before diving headfirst into a hilariously unfiltered breakdown of the latest Love Island madness. From messy relationships to all-time toxic moments, the boys react in real time to one of the wildest reality TV weeks yet.
But it’s not all jokes—this episode comes with a major announcement. The crew is hitting pause for July, teasing big upgrades, new content, and a stronger return in August that’s set to take Jury of Your Peers to the next level.
Tap in for laughs, hot takes, and a send-off that sets the stage for what’s coming next.
Jun 15, 2026
Jun 15, 2026
59 min
Episode 38 of Jury of Your Peers “Gas Station Basket” is a perfect storm of petty debates, outrageous requests, and absolute snack chaos.
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy kick things off with a heated discussion on volunteer hours—should rules be enforced to the letter, or is there room to cut some slack? The conversation quickly spirals into personal stories, school frustrations, and the fine line between doing what’s right and just being that guy.
Then things go completely off the rails with a story that starts simple—“grab some snacks”—and turns into one of the most unhinged convenience store orders imaginable. The guys break down where generosity turns into entitlement, the unwritten rules of favors, and why some requests just cross the line.
Packed with hilarious tangents on gas station snack rankings, childhood memories, and everyday annoyances, this episode delivers nonstop laughs with just enough real-life debate to keep things interesting.
Tap in and decide for yourself… when does a simple favor become way too much?
Jun 8, 2026
Jun 8, 2026
1hr 5 min
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back and firing on all cylinders—debating everything from what they'd do with lottery millions to whether parents are entitled to a cut… before diving into one of the wildest stories yet. When a fed-up group of siblings hires professional cleaners to expose their mom’s nonstop complaints, things spiral fast—and the fallout is messier than the house ever was.
With side tangents on golf handicaps, Pokémon logic, and what “life-changing money” really means, this episode blends sharp takes, real-life debates, and unfiltered humor into one of their most entertaining discussions yet.
Is it ever okay to prove a point like that… or did they go too far? Tap in and decide for yourself.
Jun 1, 2026
Jun 1, 2026
23 min
Episode 16 of JYD Deliberation Room is here, and it’s chaos in the best way. The boys finally dive into their FIRST listener-submitted story—and it does NOT disappoint. What starts as a simple high school summer job painting a house in brutal Texas heat turns into a legendary mistake involving ladders, long days, and a VERY questionable “artistic choice” left behind on the roof.
When the job is done and the money is paid, everything seems fine… until a call comes in that flips the whole story upside down. Now it’s time for Darrien, Bello, and Paddy to break it down: Was it harmless teenage stupidity, or a full-blown asshole move?
Plus, the crew debates where the line is between “kids being kids” and real accountability when money, trust, and consequences are involved.
🎙️ Listener stories are officially LIVE—send yours in and you might be next on the stand.
Tap in, subscribe, and join the jury.
May 25, 2026
May 25, 2026
48 min
This week, Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back in the courtroom delivering unfiltered verdicts and absolutely roasting some wild Reddit drama. From a grown man living rent-free while dodging his parents, to a full-blown family meltdown featuring “Hulk Mode” outbursts and a brother who might be the worst teammate of all time—this episode has it all.
The boys break down entitlement, family loyalty, and when it’s time to actually get your life together… all while going off the rails in the best way possible.
May 18, 2026
May 18, 2026
58 min
The boys are back (after a missed week they definitely won’t repeat 👀) and diving straight into wild Reddit dilemmas: one uncle secretly stocking food for his overlooked niece while her athlete brothers devour everything in sight, and a brutally honest homeowner refusing to hang their daughter-in-law’s… questionable art.
Along the way, things spiral into golf meltdowns, Midwest weather struggles, and toxic parenting debates.
It’s unfiltered, it’s unhinged, and it’s classic Darrien, Bello, and Paddy.
May 4, 2026
May 4, 2026
56 min
Episode 34 gets chaotic in the best way. The boys dive into a wild lineup of Reddit dilemmas—starting with a 19-year-old who installs a hidden camera to catch his mom snooping. From privacy vs. “my house, my rules” debates to completely unhinged tangents about high school trauma, and “banana boy” moments, nothing stays on track—and that’s exactly why it works.
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy play judge, jury, and executioner once again, handing out verdicts with zero hesitation (and questionable logic), while somehow spiraling into stories about prom disasters, family drama, and the absolute chaos of growing up.
Apr 27, 2026
Apr 27, 2026
1hr 4 min
From performance plans turning into Lego therapy, to relationship meltdowns that go way too far, the boys dive headfirst into one of the wildest Reddit stories yet. What happens when you torch your partner’s hobbies… and suddenly they become a completely different person? Yeah, it gets messy. Along the way, expect the kind of off-the-rails banter you’ve come to expect. Plus, the guys celebrate podcast growth, shout out their international fans, and somehow spiral into a full breakdown of social life, hobbies, and why Lego sets might actually save relationships. Funny, raw, and a little too real—this one’s a must-listen.
Apr 20, 2026
Apr 20, 2026
36 min
“Wedding Crasher” takes you from Miami to Texas with the boys as they recap back-to-back weddings filled with emotional speeches, wild dance floors, language barriers, and one very questionable getaway plan. From heartwarming moments to absolute disaster, this episode has everything—including a story that escalates way faster than it should.
Love, laughs, and a little bit of legal trouble… step into the deliberation room—because this one gets out of hand fast.
Apr 13, 2026
Apr 13, 2026
51 min
From a “Pomeranian smuggler” Speedo incident that clears out a house real quick, to brutally honest debates on entitled family, freeloading siblings, and whether refusing to pay your parents rent makes you the villain… the boys are in rare form.
Paddy, Darrien, and Bello tackle wild Reddit stories, spiral into hilarious tangents about Disney prices, toxic landlords, and generational money drama—and somehow end up questioning reality itself (and turtles??).
If you like unfiltered takes, unhinged stories, and the kind of humor that goes from zero to “what did I just hear” in seconds… this one’s for you.



