Jury of Your Peers

Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.

Episodes

Apr 6, 2026

1hr 1 min

New math? Yeah… we’re not buying it. In Episode 31, Paddy, Darrien, and Bello are back in the courtroom—sleep-deprived, slightly unhinged, and ready to hand out guilty verdicts like candy. From a parent going to war over a ridiculous math grade, to a streetcar stare-down that almost turns into something way worse, the boys break it all down with zero filter. Expect chaotic debates on school systems, “new math,” awkward public encounters, and why sometimes… you have to make a scene. Unpredictable, hilarious, and just a little bit unhinged—welcome back to Jury of Your Peers.

Mar 30, 2026

30 min


Paddy, Darrien, and Bello are back in the Deliberation Room—fresh off a wedding, running on no sleep, and spiraling into everything from feeling ancient at the bar to the absolute heartbreak (and redemption) of Punch the Monkey. Somewhere along the way, they debate getting famous before 35, roast the next generation, and ask the real question: if you had superpowers… would you actually be the hero?
Unfiltered, off-the-rails, and somehow still relatable—this is the kind of chaos you don’t want to miss.
 
 
 

Mar 23, 2026

1hr 2 min

Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back with “Gooner Werewolf”, a chaotic ride through wild Reddit AITA stories, questionable life decisions, and the kind of conversations that spiral way off the rails. From marriage celebrations and behind-the-scenes wedding stories (yes… there’s even a near podcast plug during a speech 👀) to debates about controlling spouses, passive-aggressive behavior, and watching “forbidden” movies—nothing is safe from judgment.
This episode features:
A husband replacing everything his wife “organizes” out of existence 🧠💥
A relationship clash over R-rated movies and personal freedom 🍿
The boys arguing, roasting each other, and somehow ending up on completely different sides
Classic off-topic tangents, absurd takes, and the birth of the “gooner werewolf”
Plus: wedding recaps, podcast growth milestones, and the usual mix of chaos, honesty, and hilarious overreactions.
If you like unfiltered debates, ridiculous humor, and three guys acting like a jury that absolutely should NOT be in charge—this one’s for you.

Mar 16, 2026

58 min

This week the boys are BACK in the courtroom and the chaos is dialed all the way up. From cereal-fueled “big back” confessions to the dangers of leaving snacks unattended, nothing is safe in this episode. 🥣
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy debate some wild Am I The A-hole stories including:
A $500 teapot destroyed by a “helpful” friend 🫖
A dorm roommate getting charged a “snack tax” for constant food sampling 🍜
The eternal struggle of roommates, late-night cravings, and missing cereal
Along the way the guys spiral into debates about expensive hobbies, drunk food rankings, Magic cards worth millions, and why turning down the radio helps you see while driving. Plus Bello debuts his new soundboard… which immediately goes off the rails.
Is the teapot owner justified? Is the snack tab petty or fair? And how dangerous is a pantry when a real Big Back gets home?
Grab a drink, hit play, and let the Jury decide. ⚖️

Mar 9, 2026

38 min

Welcome back to the JYP Deliberation Room — the bite-sized chaos of Jury of Your Peers where Darrien, Bello, and Paddy ditch the courtroom and let the conversation run wild.
In Episode 13, the boys gear up for St. Patrick’s Day while celebrating a massive life moment — wedding season is officially here. With Bello already married and Darrien’s wedding right around the corner, the crew reflects on friendship, groomsmen memories, and how a random work friendship turned into a lifelong brotherhood.
But this wouldn’t be Deliberation Room without the chaos.
☘️ Paddy breaks down the real spelling of “Paddy” and his Irish roots🍻 The boys relive the legendary Milwaukee Shamrock Shuffle bar crawl🍔 A heated debate over the GOAT drunk foods (McDonald’s, Domino’s, Cookout, and more)🍕 A possibly criminal food combo: pizza dipped in nacho cheese📩 Plus a call for listeners to send in their wild stories, food combos, and Reddit cases
Between wedding hype, St. Paddy’s traditions, and late-night food takes that might start arguments in the comments, this episode is exactly what Deliberation Room is meant to be — friends talking nonsense and somehow making it meaningful.
Grab a pint, throw on some green, and welcome to Episode 13 of JYP Deliberation Room. 🍀

Mar 2, 2026

50 min

Episode 28 might be the one that finally gets us banned from Thanksgiving.
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back — and Paddy earns a brand-new nickname after delivering the most insane washer/dryer analogy in podcast history. Yes… the camera had to go off. Yes… it’s that bad.
On the docket this week:
🧺 Is someone the asshole for refusing to wash their sister’s boyfriend’s greasy laundry?Family favors, guilt-tripping, “expensive washers,” and a debate that spirals into thong confessions and serial killer hypotheticals. Normal stuff.
💸 Is someone wrong for calling out family members who owe them €8,000… but somehow can afford a vacation in Ibiza?This one gets HEATED. Loans with no contract. “You’re a disappointment.” Family entitlement. Restaurant debt. Pride. And the boys absolutely unload on what might be the most infuriating money story yet.
It’s loud. It’s unfiltered. It’s slightly unhinged.And yes — Paddy is officially “Washing Machine.”
Welcome to Episode 28 of Jury of Your Peers.Grab your gavel… and maybe don’t lend your family eight grand.

Feb 23, 2026

55 min

The courtroom is OPEN and the vibes are reckless in Episode 27 of Jury of Your Peers. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back on YouTube and immediately spiraling into relationship politics, marriage hot takes, and the age-old question: when do you stand on principle… and when do you just eat it?
First case: a messy post-breakup housing situation where a man evicts his ex after she refuses to sign a lease. Is he protecting himself financially — or just a scorned landlord raising rent out of spite? The boys go back and forth hard on this one, and the verdict splits the courtroom.
Then it’s a marriage dilemma that might hit a little too close to home: was a husband wrong for letting his wife and daughter walk across train tracks instead of waiting at the crossing gate? “You said it was fine” vs. “You should’ve known better” turns into a full-blown debate about communication, mind-reading, and whether “happy spouse, happy house” is wisdom… or surrender.
Plus: wedding countdown chaos, sports betting plugs, Colorado Avalanche propaganda, creepy campus stories, shameless social media self-promotion, and some dangerously unfiltered relationship advice.
It’s loud. It’s chaotic. It’s principled (sometimes).Welcome to Episode 27.
Grab your gavel — and maybe just wait at the train tracks.

Feb 16, 2026

28 min

Welcome back to the Deliberation Room, where Darrien, Bello, and Paddy ditch the structure and let the conversation run wild. In Episode 12, the boys go full free-flow mode — talking life after work, relationship realities, and why this side of the podcast exists: real conversations, listener stories, and whatever chaos comes up in the moment.
This episode leans into love from both ends — Bello’s wedding countdown, Valentine’s Day hot takes, dating vs marriage debates, and the pressure (and comedy) of celebrating it all at once. From “boy dinners” and suit stress to whether Valentine’s Day is heartfelt or corporate nonsense, nothing is off-limits.
It all builds to a surprisingly heartfelt finish as the guys reflect on friendship, growth, and what it means to show up for each other during life’s biggest moments.

Feb 9, 2026

49 min

Episode 26 is pure Jury of Your Peers chaos. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back on video, back on YouTube, and immediately off the rails. From Wi-Fi disasters and parasocial jokes to stripper-name debates that somehow turn into a moral courtroom battle, this one spirals fast.
First up: a Reddit story that breaks the internet — is someone the asshole for changing their niece’s name after gaining custody? A jail sentence, a name spelled criminally wrong, and one of the most heated baby-name debates the pod has ever seen lead to a rare clean sweep… with plenty of collateral damage.
Then the boys tackle a family showdown straight out of a nightmare: is a couple wrong for telling their in-laws they’ll never live with them after backing out of promised childcare? Entitlement, retirement plans, and a bold assumption during a house tour turn into an all-time in-law reckoning — and one of the funniest verdict segments yet.
Along the way: Toledo catch strays, the Two Minute Drill gets plugged, Bello’s internet fights for its life, wild hypotheticals fly, and the guys remind everyone why the internet should never be taken seriously.
It’s loud. It’s unhinged. It’s somehow still judgmental.

Feb 1, 2026

55 min

Big news, people — Jury of Your Peers is officially on YouTube. You can finally see the faces behind the chaos, the blank apartment walls, the cat trees, and the unhinged reactions in real time.
To celebrate Episode 25, Darrien, Bello, and Paddy dive straight into peak Reddit insanity. First up: a brutal group project gone wrong when the person who did all the work somehow gets the worst grade. Confidence vs effort, school politics, and why group projects are a scam from hell.
Then the boys break down an all-time family dinner disaster: a daughter’s boyfriend shows up to her parents’ house wearing a shirt that absolutely should not exist. What follows is a Walmart trip, a forced wardrobe change, a dad masterclass in discipline, and one of the most satisfying updates in podcast history.
Along the way: moving chaos, social media plugs, anime math, Macaulay Culkin as a unit of measurement, and the official return of Jury deliberations after the longest break yet.
We’re rusty. We’re loud. We’re visual now.

Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125