Jury of Your Peers
Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.
Listen on:
Episodes
Dec 24, 2025
Dec 24, 2025
28 min
It’s Christmas Eve, the final episode of the year, and the boys are getting reflective… kind of. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy close out Year One by pulling back the curtain on how Jury of Your Peers came to life—celebrating the wins, the chaos, and the moments that defined the show (yes, Poop Knife makes an appearance).
Merry Christmas from the Jury—and buckle up for what’s coming next year. 🎄🎙️
Dec 15, 2025
Dec 15, 2025
45 min
The courtroom is loud, caffeinated, and absolutely unhinged in Episode 24 of Jury of Your Peers. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy kick things off with some hard-earned relationship wisdom (including a public service announcement every couple needs to hear: dap up your husbands).
First on the docket: a woman blindsided by her mom’s attempt to orchestrate a surprise arranged marriage like it’s medieval Europe. Surprise house visits, family pressure, and the classic line “this is how it used to be done” send the boys into a full breakdown of boundaries, culture clashes, and why your life is not a nostalgia project.
Then things get heavier with a post-divorce saga involving a wildly unconventional custody setup, a shared house, a new fiancée, and an ex who suddenly doesn’t want to follow the rules she wrote eight years ago. Selling the childhood home, unspoken expectations, commitment issues, and whether anyone here is actually the asshole sparks one of the most nuanced deliberations yet.
Along the way: college football distractions, podcast meta chaos, TikTok bribery, questionable betting advice, and the usual side quests that make Jury of Your Peers what it is.
Dec 8, 2025
Dec 8, 2025
51 min
The boys are back and things get real in Episode 24 of Jury of Your Peers. This week, Darrien, Bello, and Paddy dive into a wild pair of AITA stories—starting with a French-Canadian friendship gone sideways when a “French” baby name turns out to be… Italian. From cultural obsession to questionable naming decisions, the crew unpacks every red flag with trademark chaos.
But that’s just the warm-up. The pod spirals into streaming-service warfare, why Disney and YouTube TV nearly ruined college football Saturdays, the horrors of Peacock, getting tattoos in languages you don’t understand, and how white-guy confidence can bulldoze an entire culture.
Plus: the guys tease their first-ever fan-submitted story, drop questionable parenting advice, debate life sentences and Star Wars ethics, and get interrupted by a surprise feline guest appearance.
It’s unhinged. It’s educational (kind of). It’s chaotic in all the right ways.
Dec 1, 2025
Dec 1, 2025
47 min
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back in the booth and absolutely unhinged in this chaotic, laugh-til-you-choke episode. From an open-relationship disaster where a boyfriend fumbles harder than anyone in podcast history, to a pair of seven-year-old “cadet gooners” terrorizing their neighbor’s window, the boys break down two Reddit sagas with peak comedy and peak judgment.
Along the way they roast delusional dating confidence, debate the laws of open-relationship physics (spoiler: women always win), expose Bello’s last-name superpower, and reveal why Paddy might actually be a demon. Plus—follow the socials before the boys force Paddy to honor a dangerously vague TikTok contract he definitely signed.
Strap in, hit play, and let the deliberations begin.
Nov 24, 2025
Nov 24, 2025
54 min
The boys are back for Part Two of one of the craziest stories to ever hit JYP. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy pick up right where last week’s cliffhanger left off—because the Reddit saga did not slow down.
Our poster finally confronts his ex, her infamous “boy best friend” Alex, and a Halloween party that spirals into chaos. Matching costumes, unwanted advances, emotional manipulation, and a shocking turn about who’s actually been lying this whole time… yeah, this one gets messy.
Plus, behind-the-scenes updates, TikTok shoutouts, questionable editing choices, and the boys wrangle with the real—and often overlooked—topic of male boundaries and assault.
Grab your gavel. Grab your popcorn. This is Jury of Your Peers at its most chaotic, dramatic, and unfiltered yet.
Nov 19, 2025
Nov 19, 2025
32 min
The boys are back in The Deliberation Room—and this time Darrien takes a back seat while Bello and Paddy grab the wheel for a chaotic, hilarious deep-dive into the Internet Invitational shaking up the golf world. From Barstool drama to million-dollar stakes, angry captains, and one content creator who slept through a life-changing opportunity, this episode has controversy, chirping, and pure sports-fan insanity.
Plus, the guys talk team dynamics, athlete mentality, and why this creator-led tournament might be the start of an entirely new golf league.
Nov 10, 2025
Nov 10, 2025
56 min
The courtroom is back in session! Darrien, Bello, and Paddy hit the 20-episode milestone with full-volume energy (literally… apologies to your ears). This week, the guys dive into FriesGuy37 and his insane mission to prove his wife is a serial fry thief — complete with hidden-camera evidence, a setup involving the kid, and a reaction that sends the whole family into emotional DEFCON 1. Is he the asshole? Why is everyone hungry and angry? We deliberate.
Then the crew jumps into relationship chaos part one: the boyfriend whose girlfriend’s grandparents cannot stop calling him Alex — her best friend… or is he? What starts as a name mix-up spirals into a week-long silent treatment, bakery co-worker side-eye, and a ride request straight to Alex’s house. Red flags are everywhere, and the boys break down the drama with peak commentary.
Plus: Jury of Your Peers celebrates 20 episodes, half a year of chaos, 10+ Deliberation Rooms, TikTok explosions, and Paddy still ignoring the Twitter account.
Grab your wigs and prep the gavels — it’s Episode 20 of Jury of Your Peers. Let’s judge.
Nov 3, 2025
Nov 3, 2025
55 min
Darrien, Bello, and Paddy are back and louder than ever for Episode 19 of Jury of Your Peers! Things go completely off the rails before the first case even starts — from goat jokes to gavel mishaps to plotting their inevitable documentary, the chaos is at an all-time high.
This week’s docket includes:⚖️ “Am I the Asshole for Giving My Mother-in-Law a Fake House Key?” – A Christmas dinner disaster turns into a courtroom showdown. Is she the villain… or the victim of a snoopy MIL and a mama’s boy husband?💰 “Am I the Asshole for Not Telling My Wife About My Son’s Inheritance?” – When promises to a late wife clash with blended family finances, the jury has to decide what’s fair and what’s sacred.
Expect unfiltered takes, wild tangents, plenty of laughs, and a few surprisingly deep moments as the guys weigh in on love, loyalty, and boundaries gone bad.
Oct 29, 2025
Oct 29, 2025
47 min
In this episode of Jury of Your Peers, the boys take you deep into the heart of Louisiana for a bachelor party weekend unlike any other — from wild nights on Bourbon Street to a legendary game day at LSU’s Death Valley.
Join Darrien, Bello, and Paddy as they relive their New Orleans and Baton Rouge bachelor party adventure — complete with bottomless vodka brunches at Lula’s, hand grenades on Bourbon, parrots, panic, and pure SEC chaos. Expect college football talk, travel stories, drunken debacles, and enough inside jokes to make you feel like you were right there in the French Quarter.
The crew also plugs their sister show The Two Minute Drill, the home for college football fanatics craving hot takes, bad bets, and raw emotion about the Brian Kelly firing and everything LSU.
Oct 20, 2025
Oct 20, 2025
58 min
When your girlfriend’s cooking is better than most restaurants, is it really so wrong to never want to go out? In this episode of Jury of Your Peers, Bello, Darien, and Paddy take on a viral Am I the Asshole post that spirals into debates about love, logic, and Olive Garden.
Along the way, the guys unpack bachelor party stories from Death Valley, argue about whether Indiana is “East Coast,” and tackle the real moral dilemma — if your fiancée turned into a zombie, would you put her down?
It’s a chaotic mix of relationship hot takes, food snobbery, and philosophical nonsense — just another day in the Jury.



