Jury of Your Peers

Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.

Episodes

Oct 13, 2025

1hr 6 min

First up, a bride-to-be is planning a "free wedding" by shifting every single cost and huge labor demands—from an elaborate, multi-tier fondant cake to venue, flowers, and invitations—onto her friends and family. Then, the boys dive into a dramatic club encounter: A guy on leave from deployment tries to return a high-end Louis Vuitton purse to a drunk woman, only to be met with an audible "ew" and laughter from her friends, which leads to some choice words. Was this a justified reaction to a humiliating insult, especially for a guy struggling with low self-esteem, or did he go too far?
The hosts explore men's mental health, the rarity of male compliments, and the uncalled-for rudeness of the woman's reaction in this Week's Episode of Jury of your Peers

Oct 8, 2025

37 min

The boys are back and barely awake after a long weekend of college football, trash talk, and bad bets — but there’s no rest when Ayesha Curry hits the “Call Her Daddy” podcast. Darrien, Bello, and Paddy break down that viral clip, diving into relationships, fame, and why saying “I didn’t want kids” on camera might not be the flex she thought it was.
They unpack what happens when private conversations go public — with the usual mix of hot takes, hilarious hypotheticals, and unfiltered honesty. Plus, the guys tease bachelor trips, broke-boy blues, and the long-awaited visual drop for the pod.

Sep 29, 2025

55 min

Darrien, Bello & Paddy tackle their most split case yet: a 17-year-old accused of “ruining” her mom’s marriage by never accepting her stepdad, plus a heated follow-up on whether a mom is wrong for refusing to let her kids travel to Dubai with their father. Between Elf vs. Polar Express hot takes, Dom Toretto family jokes, and some very real talk about step-parenting, custody, and boundaries, this one goes off the rails in the best way.

Sep 22, 2025

54 min

Lies, life insurance, and a whole lot of family drama. In this episode, Paddy, Darrien, and Bello tackle a sticky situation: a parent lied about a life insurance policy, and now someone is feeling betrayed. The hosts weigh in with their verdict, but who's the real jerk in this story? Plus, they dive into social media marketing, the pressure to get married, and how much it costs to raise kids these days. Get ready for some laughs and candid takes on the complexities of modern life.

Sep 17, 2025

41 min

Get ready for a wild ride with the boys from Deliberation Room! Fresh off a hectic weekend, the hosts dive deep into the mind-blowing Netflix documentary, Unknown Number. From small-town drama and high school catfishing to a shocking, un-spoilable twist, they break down every bizarre detail, including the psychological motives of the perpetrator. Plus, get the scoop on Paddy's new sports podcast, Two Minute Drill. It's a true-crime deep dive with a side of tired laughs.

Sep 8, 2025

1hr 25 sec

In this episode of Jury of Your Peers, hosts Bello, Darien, and Paddy dive into a heated Reddit AITA case: Is it wrong to refuse to date someone because of their religion? The crew debates dating dealbreakers, discrimination, and how honesty can sometimes turn you into the villain.
Then in the second half, the gang tackles a new AITA story — a partner convinced they can keep a spotless house and spotless kids. The conversation spirals into OCD-level cleaning habits, impossible parenting standards, and hilarious toddler horror stories (sticky hands, pink eye, and poop knife crossovers included). They debate whether this is simply neat freak behavior or a clinical obsession, and deliver a brutally honest reality check on life with children. 
The episode wraps with fantasy football draft talk and Paddy’s NFL Thursday Night betting picks, including a juicy Jalen Hurts touchdown prop.

Sep 1, 2025

59 min

Step into Jury of Your Peers Ep. 13 where hosts Bello, Darien, and Paddy put on their metaphorical judge wigs to deliver hilarious, unfiltered verdicts on the wildest “Am I The Asshole?” Reddit stories. In this episode, the trio tackles a chaotic babysitting nightmare involving flying baseballs, dented drywall, and a 22-year-old unfairly blamed for damage she didn’t cause. Then, emotions run high as they dissect a family feud sparked by parents refusing to accept their son’s deaf wife—and the fallout when they want to meet their grandkids. Expect sharp takes, laugh-out-loud banter, and surprising life lessons on boundaries, responsibility, and respect. Perfect for fans of comedy, storytelling, and outrageous internet drama.

Aug 27, 2025

42 min

This week on Deliberation Room, the boys return from a wild long weekend celebrating Bello's joint bachelor and bachelorette party at Lake Norman, North Carolina. From a hibachi chef spraying sake in every direction (and yes, into someone’s ear), to competitive camp-style games like tug-of-war, three-legged races, and even flipping hot dogs and rubber chickens, this trip had it all. We relive the epic moments, including Jeopardy showdowns, pizza vs. steakhouse debates, paddleboard fails, and a golf round that featured pristine bunkers, questionable starters, and near-death tee shots. Whether you’re planning your own bachelor party, love hilarious travel stories, or just want to hear three friends roast each other while swapping outrageous memories, this episode delivers nonstop laughs, chaos, and friendship.

Aug 18, 2025

1hr 5 min

On this weeks episode of Jury of Your Peers, Bello, Darrien, and Paddy take on a viral Am I the Asshole case where a man kicks his mom out for cooking him breakfast he never asked for. What seems like a harmless favor spirals into arguments about food waste, boundaries, and respect, leaving the Jury to decide if he was protecting himself or just being an ungrateful jerk. Then the gang takes a sharp turn into family drama, is it ok to plan a family dinner without the children's spouses? Or is it emotionally manipulative? The gang dives into it all on this weeks episode. 

Aug 11, 2025

1hr 12 min

The JYP crew kicks off Episode 11 with a chaotic dive into one of Reddit’s most divisive “Am I The Asshole?” stories — a dead sister’s engagement ring used in a surprise proposal. Was it a treasured heirloom stolen, or just fair game? The debate spirals into parents vs. siblings, sentimental value vs. practicality, and how badly proposals can go wrong.
Then, things heat up again with a second AITA case: a fiancée demanding her partner stop making home-cooked meals for a friend. Is it innocent kindness or crossing relationship boundaries?
Expect unfiltered laughs, hot takes, and plenty of off-the-rails tangents from Darrien, Bello, and Paddy in this weeks new episode. 

Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125