Jury of Your Peers
Jury of Your Peers is the podcast where the internet’s most chaotic dilemmas meet the court of public opinion. Each week, hosts Erick, Paddy, and Darrien dive into the wildest stories from the AITA subreddit, serving as your unofficial jury. No drama is too petty, no post too outrageous. Who was right, who was wrong, and who just needs to log off. Come for the hot takes, stay for the heated debates.
Listen on:
Episodes
Jun 4, 2025
Jun 4, 2025
18 min
In this minisode of The Deliberation Room, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick lock in on the internet’s latest chaos: Is riding a mechanical bull three times on a date a red flag—or a power move? What started as a tweet turned into a full-blown debate about confidence, cringe, and how much is too much on date night. The crew breaks it down with laughs, logic, and zero restraint.
May 26, 2025
May 26, 2025
57 min
Episode 4 of Jury of Your Peers is pure madness. Darrien, Paddy, and Erick weigh in on AITA for telling your boyfriend’s parents you’re not his babysitter—then things take a very sharp turn. We’re talking about legendary logs, family secrets, and one unforgettable question: Do you have a poop knife? Some stories you can’t unhear. This is one of them.
May 19, 2025
May 19, 2025
54 min
In Episode 3 of Jury of Your Peers, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick step into the gray areas of morality with two spicy AITA cases: First up: should your allergies outweigh someone’s service dog at game night? Then, it’s academic warfare—what happens when your friend cheats with your notes, and you turn him in? Loyalty, ethics, and ego are all on trial.
May 13, 2025
May 13, 2025
32 min
In the first minisode of Jury of Your Peers; Deliberation Room, Darrien, Paddy, and Erick dive into the viral 100 men vs. a gorilla debate, breaking down strategy, chaos, and social dynamics. Then they pivot to golf, where the stakes, and egos, are just as wild.
It'a, fast, it's unfiltered, and it's just the beginning!
May 5, 2025
May 5, 2025
53 min
This week on Jury of Your Peers, Bello, Darrien and Paddy dive deep into a chaotic family vacation story where one man faces off against his entire family — and how it feels to get constantly interrupted in the office space.
Darrien and Paddy break down the full situation: East Coast vs West Coast energy, sibling grudges, toddler chaos, and the ultimate betrayal of putting your future spouse outside. Plus, the guys debate who really gets to wear a fedora and why being the youngest sibling is sometimes a blessing... and sometimes a curse.
Bring your vibes, your statistics, and maybe your grandma's pasta — it's time for another heated session of Jury of Your Peers.
Apr 27, 2025
Apr 27, 2025
44 min
Join Darrien, Paddy, and Erick as they dive into the absurdity of post midterm lunch etiquette, undercooked chicken, and friends who can't split a check without drama. First, we tackle the battle over who foots the bill when you’re out with friends—because apparently, the ‘split-the-check-down-the-middle’ method is a battlefield. Then we delve into a couple’s cooking woes, where one spouse’s ‘signature crunchy rice’ might just be a health hazard. Will Darrien give the guy a break? Will Paddy suggest cooking classes as the perfect passive-aggressive gift? And what’s the deal with salmonella chicken? Tune in to find out how we navigate the culinary chaos, bad manners, and other questionable decisions.



